We officially kicked off the Summer of Ice Cream this weekend by starting at the bottom of our list: Weber’s Premium Custard & Ice Cream.
Weber’s specializes in custard, which is basically ice cream made with egg yolks. If you ever make ice cream at home, you most likely are making custard (since most homemade ice cream recipes call for eggs). I’m not the biggest fan of custard vs non-egg ice cream, so I was pleased to see that they had plenty of flavors of each. The board in the picture above is only about half the flavors listed. There was another handwritten board next to it.
I got Peanut Butter Fudge Brownie ice cream, which was taking a bit of a gamble. Peanut butter ice cream can be bad. It’s a good idea but it’s hard to execute. Weber’s nailed it. So good. Kerry got the classic chocolate custard. It reminded us of the greatest frosty you’ve ever tasted. Joey had a little bit of both, and mine was so good I was trying to make up reasons why she shouldn’t have any, which she was not happy about.
One of the reasons we were interested in Weber’s is how old fashioned it is. They still use the same equipment they were using in 1931. In fact, the two machines they use to make ice cream are the last two of those machines in existence! I obviously know a thing or two about ice cream machines and I have never seen machines like these. It was very cool to taste the product that came out of them.
Weber’s is definitely keeping it simple and old fashioned. I’m not going to knock places that are inventing new flavor ideas — that’s great. But sometimes all you want are the classics. If that’s what you want, you can’t go wrong with Weber’s.
Rating: 1,931 stars out of 1,931.
One thought on “Summer of Ice Cream: Weber’s”
Andy, thanks for bringing your family to my store (Weber’s Ice Cream) to enjoy one of Summer’s rewards, Ice Cream. We do NOT make Frozen Custard. Never have, never will. Frozen Custard was invented by farmers (in the late 1800’s) who added the fat from egg yolks to replace the cream they had skimmed and sold to dairies. Sharp operators in NYC (Kohr’s claims it was them) REPLACED the wildfire sensation known as Fresh Ice Cream (discovered on the Jersey Shore, Summer 1919) with the cheapened farm family replacement (Frozen Custard mix ingredients only cost 4/7 of what Premium Ice Cream ingredients cost), because everyone had heard of it (including here in Cleveland) but so few had tasted it that Kohr’s folks thought that if they started “popularizing” Frozen Custard, people would forget about Fresh Ice Cream, thinking they were one and the same. Apparently, they were right. They had help from Dairy Marketing Associations that wanted to take retail ice cream sales away from drug stores. These DMA’s wanted to contract farmers to ONLY sell their cream to them (“we’ll buy more of your milk to make ice cream with it”) and went after independents and dairies that did not comply. The combination of replacement and advertising worked, the DMA’s were able to convince the impressionable populace that “if it is scooped soft from a tub, it must be frozen custard”. Weber’s is an offshoot of the Soeder Dairy Company which operated Euclid Beach’s famed “Dairy Whip” stand. Weber’s is the only place in the world that makes Vintage and Modern Ice Cream, because we are the only ones with the machines to do it and the history, also. Contact me if you want to be shown the difference.